Lemma 4, p. 84 — the AV-only total variable profit strictly decreases beyond n*_{HV,i}
ProvedAVRideHail.MonopolyCapacity.lemma4_profit_decreasingConsider a scenario with potential demand mass in a market with , , , , constant HV reservation earnings (), and AV variable cost . Suppose the market is loose (condition (33)) and is its maximal stable pure-HV equilibrium, with . When AVs serve the market alone with a fleet of vehicles, they serve the demand , and the total variable profit of the monopoly supplier is (250)
This function of is strictly decreasing on .
Lemma 4 is the reason a monopoly never deploys more AVs than the pure-HV fleet size: beyond the loss in price outweighs the extra demand served.
Formalization Note. The paper's Assumption 2 is written as the loose-market condition (33) of App. B.1.1. The paper's §6.2 sets ; the remaining parameter positivity is the paper's standing setting. The domain is not cut at : for larger fleets the formula's price is negative, as on the page.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_AVRideHail_MonopolyCapacity_Model
namespace AVRideHail.MonopolyCapacity
theorem lemma4_profit_decreasing (P : AVRideHail.PureHV.MarketParams) (ha : 0 < P.a) (hr0 : 0 < P.r)
(hr1 : P.r < 1) (ht2 : 0 < P.t2) (hV : 0 < P.V) (hw0 : 0 < P.w0) (halpha : P.alpha = 0)
(cv : ℝ) (hcv : 0 < cv) (m : ℝ) (hm : 0 < m) (hloose : AVRideHail.PureHV.LooseMarket P m)
(dstar : ℝ) (hdstar : AVRideHail.PureHV.IsMaxStableEq P m dstar) :
StrictAntiOn (fun n => AVRideHail.PureHV.priceFn P m (dBar P n) * dBar P n * P.t2 - cv * n)
(Set.Ici (AVRideHail.PureHV.nMin P dstar)) := by sorry
end AVRideHail.MonopolyCapacity
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.