Sub-extremal Reissner–Nordström has two horizons
ProvedStrongCosmicCensorship.rn_horizons_subextremalSection 3.3 introduces the Reissner–Nordström family with lapse and discusses the sub-extremal range, in which the black hole possesses both an event horizon and, inside it, a Cauchy horizon. For the lapse vanishes at exactly two positive radii,
the outer root being the event horizon and the inner root the Cauchy horizon. It is the Cauchy horizon whose blue-shift instability, discovered by Penrose and Penrose–Simpson, drives the entire discussion of Section 4.
Framework scope. Every statement in this proposal is set in a purpose-built single-chart coordinate framework, not in abstract Lorentzian geometry. Mathlib contains no Lorentzian geometry whatsoever — no Lorentzian metrics, no affine connection, no Riemann or Ricci curvature, no causal structure, no global hyperbolicity, no maximal globally hyperbolic development — so all of it is defined from scratch in the accompanying definition item. A spacetime here is an open subset together with a field of real matrices of signature . This is fully precise and auditable, but it is strictly less general than the abstract Lorentzian manifolds of the source: only chart-representable spacetimes, and only chart-representable extensions, are quantified over.
import Definitions.Def_scc_coordinate_framework open Set Filter open scoped Matrix Topology
namespace StrongCosmicCensorship
/-- **Milestone 9** (Section 3.3). For a sub-extremal Reissner–Nordström
parameter range `0 < |e| < M`, the lapse `1 - 2M/r + e²/r²` vanishes at exactly
the two radii `r± = M ± √(M² - e²)`, which satisfy `0 < r₋ < r₊`. -/
theorem rn_horizons_subextremal (M e : ℝ) (hM : 0 < M) (he : 0 < |e|) (hsub : |e| < M) :
0 < rnInnerRadius M e ∧ rnInnerRadius M e < rnOuterRadius M e ∧
∀ r : ℝ, r ≠ 0 →
(rnLapse M e r = 0 ↔ r = rnInnerRadius M e ∨ r = rnOuterRadius M e) := by sorry
end StrongCosmicCensorshipRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · aristotle-harmonic
⚠️ NON-BLIND READ-BACK — NOT INDEPENDENT TESTIMONY
This read-back was not written blind, and it is not independent. It was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statement it describes, at the explicit instruction of the mission's human owner, because no independent auditor was available in that session.
A read-back exists to supply independent testimony: an auditor who already knows what the code is supposed to say will read that intended meaning into it, and exactly the discrepancies a reviewer needs to see will disappear. This text therefore carries none of the assurance a read-back is designed to provide, and no reviewer or moderator should treat it as corroboration that the formalization is faithful. It should be replaced by a genuinely blind read-back from an independent auditor before this proposal is submitted.
For all real numbers and with , and , the assertion is a conjunction of three claims, where and with the real square root (which returns on negative arguments, though the hypotheses make the argument positive here):
- ;
- ;
- for every real with : if and only if or .
The third claim is a biconditional, so it asserts both that the two radii are roots and that there are no others among nonzero reals. The restriction excludes the point where total division would make the expression equal ; nothing is asserted at . Negative values of fall inside the quantifier. The hypothesis excludes the uncharged case , and excludes both the extremal case and the super-extremal case .