Theorem (4.4) — F is flow-invariant for Lipschitz X iff X(x) ⊆ T_F(x) on F
ProvedClarkeGradients.FlowInvariance.flowInvariant_iff_subset_tangentConeLet be a multifunction from to whose values are nonempty and compact, and suppose is Lipschitz in the sense of (4.2). Let be a nonempty closed subset of . The following are equivalent:
- is flow-invariant for (4.3): every trajectory (4.1) of starting in stays in on ;
- for each , is tangent to at :
where is the Clarke tangent cone (3.6).
The theorem shows that Clarke's tangent cone is exactly the right notion of tangency for invariance of closed sets under Lipschitz differential inclusions; it contains the classical invariance theorems of Bony and Brezis for Lipschitz vector fields.
Formalization Note " nonempty and compact for every " is the standing assumption stated once at the top of §4 (p. 259) and is an explicit hypothesis. Trajectories are absolutely continuous on with almost everywhere, encoded with HasDerivAt. is the Clarke tangent cone (the polar of the normal cone (3.1)), not Mathlib's Bouligand tangentConeAt. The Lipschitz constant in (4.2) is global.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ClarkeGradients_FlowInvariance_tangentCone import Definitions.Def_ClarkeGradients_FlowInvariance_IsLipschitzMultifunction import Definitions.Def_ClarkeGradients_FlowInvariance_FlowInvariant
namespace ClarkeGradients.FlowInvariance
/-- Clarke (1975), Theorem (4.4): let `X` be a Lipschitz multifunction (4.2) whose values `X(x)`
are nonempty and compact (standing assumption of §4), and let `F` be a nonempty closed subset of
`ℝⁿ`. Then `F` is flow-invariant for `X` (4.3) if and only if `X(x) ⊆ T_F(x)` for every `x ∈ F`,
where `T_F(x)` is the Clarke tangent cone (3.6). -/
theorem flowInvariant_iff_subset_tangentCone {n : ℕ}
(X : EuclideanSpace ℝ (Fin n) → Set (EuclideanSpace ℝ (Fin n)))
(hX : ∀ x, (X x).Nonempty ∧ IsCompact (X x)) (hLip : IsLipschitzMultifunction X)
(F : Set (EuclideanSpace ℝ (Fin n))) (hF : F.Nonempty) (hFc : IsClosed F) :
FlowInvariant X F ↔ ∀ x ∈ F, X x ⊆ tangentCone F x := by sorry
end ClarkeGradients.FlowInvariance
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5-5
Let and write for -dimensional Euclidean space with the usual Euclidean norm. The statement quantifies over the following data:
- a set-valued map , which assigns a subset to every point ;
- a subset .
It assumes:
- for every (not only ), the set is nonempty and compact;
- satisfies the bundle predicate ;
- is nonempty;
- is closed in .
Under these hypotheses it asserts the equivalence
where is the bundle's . Three names in this statement are defined in the bundle, not in standard libraries: , and . Their code was not provided with this declaration, so this read-back cannot say what they mean. In particular, it cannot confirm:
- which Lipschitz-type condition on is assumed (for example, which distance between sets it uses and whether the constant is global or local);
- what notion of invariance "flow-invariant" means (for example, what kind of trajectories it quantifies over, on what time interval, and from which starting points);
- which tangent cone is used.
The code carries a comment describing these as Clarke's notions. That comment is documentation, not part of the checked statement, and the read-back does not rely on it. Both directions of the equivalence are asserted: the inclusion condition implies flow-invariance, and flow-invariance implies the inclusion condition. The inclusion is required for each point of individually. Nothing is required of outside except hypotheses 1 and 2, which apply everywhere.
In the degenerate case , is the one-point space . Hypothesis 1 then forces , and hypotheses 3 and 4 force . The statement reduces to . Whether either side holds, and whether hypothesis 2 is satisfied here at all, depends on the unprovided definitions. The case (the whole space) is allowed. There is no case , because hypothesis 3 excludes it. The hypotheses and compactness are satisfiable, for example by a constant singleton map. Whether they can be satisfied together with , so that the theorem is not vacuous, cannot be decided without that definition's code. The statement contains no division, natural-number subtraction, integral, supremum or extended-real arithmetic, so none of their default values arise in the displayed statement itself. Any such values inside the three bundle definitions cannot be assessed here.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.