The Riemann hypothesis concerns the complex zeros of the Riemann zeta function. A formal verification of a proposed proof must account for the actual analytic function, its exceptional arguments, and every passage from an operator identity to a statement about its zeros. The goal of this mission is to check the Riemann zeta specialization of Alessandro Maria Masullo's The Music of the Primes. The source is the draft linked in Ravi Vakil's announcement of 20 November 2026, not a subsequently revised version.
This is a formalization of a proposed argument. Its conclusions are proof obligations. Neither the announcement nor the presence of a theorem statement on this platform establishes that the argument is correct. The initial source snapshot has 940 PDF pages. Its discussion includes a general number field and unitary Hecke characters; this mission's final goal is deliberately the Riemann zeta case. Full Hecke-character generality will require additional definitions and statements.
IMPORTANT. The goal of this mission is to determine whether Masullo's specific approach is correct (with minor modifications). It is not "formalize a proof of GRH by whatever means". In particular please do not submit proofs based on results from the P2M mission formalizing the Alpoge / Claude proof (https://prove2.me/missions/Verifying_the_Alp%C3%B6ge%E2%80%93Claude_Proof_of_the_Riemann_Hypothesis).
The Riemann zeta function is initially the complex series
and then its meromorphic continuation. Lean uses Mathlib's riemannZeta. The critical strip is the open region and the critical line is . These refer to real parts, with no restriction on imaginary parts and no finite height cutoff. The logarithmic derivative is the function , on its classical domain of definition.
The broader source introduces the adele ring of a number field, its idele class group, theta-function spaces, and completions carrying convolution operators. Those objects are needed to check the source's trace calculation. They are not interchangeable with an arbitrary vector space equipped with a postulated trace identity. The source notation and conventions must be carried into definitions before its main operator theorems can be submitted as faithful Lean statements.
The final target is the mission-scoped theorem MasulloRH.mission_riemann_hypothesis:
The first source-specific milestone is the analytic conclusion asserted in §1.4.5, pp.29–30, specialized to the zeta function and expressed without the source's shift by :
The second milestone is the ensuing zero-free assertion from the same source passage:
These milestones assert their conclusions unconditionally. The trace formula and all estimates required to establish them must be proved, rather than supplied as unexamined hypotheses. The source's subsequent use of the functional equation must also be connected formally to the final critical-strip statement.
Completion means a machine-checked proof of the stated zeta target with the entire submitted dependency graph resolved. Reusing an already proved equivalence between the critical-strip formulation and Mathlib's RiemannHypothesis can identify the two interfaces; it does not solve either formulation. Numerical zero checks, established zero-free regions farther to the right, or a conditional implication from a new conjecture do not close this mission.
The local project also contains three proved background statements, obtained directly from Mathlib: the trivial negative-even zeros, the functional equation of completed zeta, and nonvanishing in the closed half-plane with real part at least one. These are available infrastructure, not new contributions attributed to Masullo and not evidence that the new milestones have been proved.
The source connects spectral traces, orbital kernel calculations, and a local trace calculation. Its claimed trace formula must remain valid as the relevant strip changes. The analytic consequence additionally requires passing to limiting families of test functions and controlling the resulting analytic functions. Formal verification must retain convergence, continuity, measure normalizations, support conditions, and dependence of bounds on the parameters; an identity of unconstrained formal sums does not provide those facts.
Theorem 12.5.1.1 is stated on pp.519–520. Its proof cites the spectral calculation, the orbital calculation, and the local calculation. The downloaded Chapter 13, p.522, contains editorial placeholders, including an absent final theorem statement. The overview in §§1.4.2–1.4.5 explains the intended limiting argument. Reconstructing this missing exposition is an explicit mathematical task, and no missing passage is silently treated as a theorem already proved.
The environment is Mathlib revision 0df444a360eaa60ab8c11dca51a86af692955474, with Lean 4.33.1 and implicit variable creation disabled. Scalars and function arguments are complex numbers; inequalities on real parts are real inequalities. Analyticity is Mathlib's AnalyticAt ℂ. Both new milestones exclude the pole at one. The totalized quotient in Lean has a value even when its denominator vanishes; analyticity on a neighborhood remains the asserted property and must be justified.
The initial draft contains the shared RH goal and two precise analytic milestones. The full adelic trace formula and its intermediate infrastructure are mapped by source location in the accompanying local project and remain to be encoded. New statements should follow the frozen source, receive independent read-backs, and reuse existing platform definitions where they match. Submitting an unresolved source step as an open child preserves the obligation; assuming it in the final goal would weaken the mission.
This mission now uses the dedicated goal MasulloRH.mission_riemann_hypothesis. It has exactly the same critical-strip RH statement as the former shared goal, but its graph is reserved for Masullo’s argument and explicitly audited repairs. Direct and indirect dependencies on the Alpöge–Claude RH proof, generic RH assumptions used to discharge upstream obligations, and reverse reductions that feed the downstream nonvanishing goal back into the trace argument are outside scope. Such reductions have been retired from the active Masullo graph. Shared background mathematics is retained when it does not import that RH proof.
namespace MasulloRH
/-- Mission-scoped RH goal. Its proof graph is reserved for the Masullo route. -/
theorem mission_riemann_hypothesis :
∀ s : ℂ, 0 < s.re → s.re < 1 → riemannZeta s = 0 → s.re = 1 / 2 := by sorry
end MasulloRH
For every complex number with , if then .
This is the same mathematical RH statement previously used as the globally shared goal. A dedicated declaration is necessary to isolate this mission's proof graph from the independent Alpöge–Claude mission and from other RH projects. The separate identity of the node records the project's proof-provenance scope; it adds no mathematical hypothesis and supplies no proof of RH. Only the Masullo route and explicitly audited repairs are in scope. No direct or indirect import of the Alpöge–Claude RH proof is permitted.
The initial reduction uses the source-specific right-half-plane nonvanishing target and the ordinary zeta functional equation. The actual trace calculation remains an open proof obligation.
Independent blind read-back:
For every complex number whose real part satisfies the strict inequalities , if the Riemann zeta function satisfies , then . The quantifier includes every imaginary part, including zero; the hypotheses exclude both boundary lines and , and the assertion imposes no condition on zeros outside this open strip.