Moment-angle complexes are central objects in toric topology. They convert the combinatorics of a simplicial complex into a topological space assembled from disks and circles, allowing face structure to influence homotopy and homology. When the simplicial complex triangulates a sphere, the resulting space is a moment-angle manifold. Torsion in the integral homology of these manifolds is difficult to realize in low simplicial dimension, and torsion in the homology of their based loop spaces is even more constrained. Yang Han and Keke Li's Theorem 1.7 asserts that dimension four is already universal: every finitely generated abelian group can occur as a subgroup of both homology theories for one and the same simplicial -sphere.
This mission formalizes that headline existence statement. It is not restricted to a chosen finite list of groups or primes, and it requires a common simplicial sphere rather than permitting separate witnesses for ordinary and loop homology.
Let be an abstract simplicial complex on a finite vertex set . Its geometric realization is formed from probability vectors whose supports are faces of . The condition that is a simplicial -sphere means that this realization is homeomorphic to the unit sphere .
For each face , assign a copy of the closed disk at vertices in and the boundary circle at vertices outside . The associated moment-angle complex is
The all-ones point is a canonical basepoint. Write for the based loop space with the compact-open topology. For a space , the mission uses total integral singular homology
as an additive abelian group. Saying that an abelian group is a subgroup means that there is an injective additive homomorphism .
For every finitely generated abelian group , prove that there are an integer and a simplicial complex on Fin m such that and there are injective homomorphisms
The quantifier order matters: the same and the same must support both embeddings. The target concerns additive subgroups of total graded homology; it does not require the two embeddings to land in the same degree or to preserve multiplicative structures.
The theorem gives a universality statement for moment-angle manifolds over simplicial -spheres. It says that no classification by a bounded list of torsion primes or exponents can describe all such homology and loop-homology groups. Requiring both embeddings for a single connects the ordinary topology of the manifold to its based-loop topology rather than proving two unrelated existence results.
Formalizing the theorem requires reusable foundations in several areas: finite abstract simplicial complexes, geometric realization, polyhedral products, based loop spaces, integral singular homology, graded direct sums, and additive embeddings. The published article presents a human proof; this mission records its intended main theorem as an open Lean target. The definitions do not assume the existence of the required sphere or embeddings, so a solver must supply the mathematical construction and all homological consequences.
The assertion ranges over arbitrary finitely generated abelian groups, including free parts and prime-power torsion of unbounded exponent. A finite check of selected groups cannot establish the target. The same finite simplicial object must simultaneously control two different homology theories, one of which is applied to an infinite-dimensional function space. Standard library support is strongest for singular homology as a functor, while concrete calculations for moment-angle spaces and loop spaces require additional bridges.
There is also a substantial representation boundary between combinatorics and topology. The face data of , the union of disk-circle products, the homeomorphism , and the induced maps on homology must all refer to compatible spaces and basepoints. A formal solution cannot replace “simplicial sphere” by a mere Boolean flag or replace homology by an arbitrary group-valued field.
Lean represents using AbstractSimplicialComplex (Fin m). Because Mathlib's structure includes singleton faces automatically, the auxiliary face predicate explicitly restores the conventional empty face where the moment-angle union needs it. The geometric realization is the standard support-restricted probability simplex, and the sphere condition is an actual homeomorphism to the Euclidean unit -sphere.
The moment-angle space is a subtype of (Fin m → ℂ) defined by the literal disk/circle coordinate condition. The loop space consists of based continuous paths with matching endpoints and carries the compact-open topology inherited from Mathlib's path construction. Homology is singularHomologyFunctor with coefficients in , and total homology is a direct sum over all natural degrees.
The statement permits the two embeddings to occupy different degrees and makes no ring-embedding claim; these choices match the source phrase “contain as a subgroup.” It rules out vacuity by requiring an actual simplicial complex, an actual sphere homeomorphism, and injective additive maps. Contributions that isolate degree-specific refinements, compute homology of standard polyhedral products, or formalize reusable loop-space equivalences are welcome, provided they reconnect to the stated root theorem.
open MomentAngle
theorem momentAngle_arbitrary_torsion
(G : Type) [AddCommGroup G] [Module.Finite ℤ G] :
∃ (m : ℕ) (_hm : 0 < m) (L : AbstractSimplicialComplex (Fin m)),
IsSimplicialFourSphere L ∧
AdditivelyEmbeds G (TotalIntegralHomology (Complex L)) ∧
AdditivelyEmbeds G (TotalIntegralHomology (BasedLoopSpace L)) := by sorry
Let be a finitely generated abelian group. Prove that there exist a natural number and an abstract simplicial complex on Fin m whose geometric realization is homeomorphic to the unit sphere , such that the same moment-angle space admits injective additive homomorphisms
Here is the union, over faces of , of coordinate products having a disk in the coordinates of and a circle elsewhere. The loop space is based at the all-ones point, and denotes the direct sum of integral singular homology over all nonnegative degrees.
The same simplicial -sphere must witness both embeddings. The claim concerns additive subgroups; the embeddings need not occupy the same homological degree or preserve a graded ring structure.
Formalization Note The sphere condition is an actual homeomorphism, the moment-angle and loop spaces are concrete topological spaces, and the two subgroup claims are explicit injective additive homomorphisms.